The Cape Girardeau City Council denied a request of two Cape Girardeau residents to build a home at the northeast corner of Lexington Avenue and Perryville Road that would also serve as an insurance office.
Since the council denied the request of Bo and Dianne Shantz, individual council members had to submit a findings-and-conclusion report stating their reasons for denial. Those reports and all other records obtained by the planning department and city staff were included with the original application.
It has been some time since the council denied a special-use permit, said Mayor Al Spradling III. Usually the council signs off on the recommendations of the Planning and Zoning Commission so no additional reports are needed, he said.
But city officials and planning commission members are at odds about what sort of development -- commercial or residential -- should be allowed at Perryville and Lexington. The issue has long been a debate among city officials, coming to the forefront every few years when projects are proposed.
The Planning and Zoning Commission approved the Shantz' request in May. A request to rezone the opposite corner of Lexington and Perryville was denied. That matter should be presented at a public hearing in August.
Bo and Dianne Shantz had requested a special-use permit to operate the insurance office instead of seeking a zoning change for the property. They appeared before the council June 19 at a public hearing on the matter.
Special-use permits are granted to the property owners seeking a zoning variance without rezoning the entire property. The permits are nontransferable and are void if the property is sold.
Several residents also appeared at the June meeting stating opposition to the special-use permit. Some also attended Monday night's meeting. The residents are opposed to commercial development on the northeast corner since it could increase traffic in the neighborhood.
The petition was signed by 22 residents in the neighborhood. All objected to the special-use permit. Because the signatures were valid, the ordinance granting the permit would have required a five-sevenths majority for passage.
Frank Stoffregen was the only council member to vote for the permit.
Spradling said several major intersections along Lexington Avenue have the potential for commercial development.
"If we aren't careful we could have a gas station or quick shop on every corner -- not that it would be the worst thing in the world but it might not be the best thing," he said. "That could be what we are faced with."
Cape Girardeau City Council action
Monday, July 17
City Hall, 401 Independence
Consent ordinances
(Second and third readings)
New ordinances (First reading)
Resolutions
(Reading and passage)
Connect with the Southeast Missourian Newsroom:
For corrections to this story or other insights for the editor, click here. To submit a letter to the editor, click here. To learn about the Southeast Missourian’s AI Policy, click here.