Organic price premiums dip as demand grows, choices multiply

DETROIT -- U.S. shoppers are still paying more for organic food, but the price premium is falling as organic options multiply.

Last year, organic food and beverages cost an average of 24 cents more per unit than conventional food, or about 7.5 percent more, according to Nielsen. That was down from a 27 cent, or 9 percent, premium in 2014.

There's a lot of variation within those numbers. The average price for a gallon of organic milk -- $4.76 -- is 88 percent higher than the $2.53 shoppers pay for a gallon of regular milk. Organic eggs have an 86 percent premium. At $4.89 per loaf, organic bread is double the cost of regular bread.

In this combination photo, regular 2 percent fat milk, left, is shown for sale at $3.69 per gallon, and organic 2 percent fat milk is shown for sale at $7.49 per gallon Jan. 17 at a grocery store in Doral, Florida.Wilfredo Lee ~ Associated Press

Parents buying organic baby food, on the other hand, pay just 3 percent more than they would for conventional baby food. In mid-January, a bunch of organic kale was 5 percent more than ordinary kale, according to the U.S. Department of Agriculture. Some organic products -- such as artichokes, soy milk and Granny Smith apples -- may even cost less than their conventional counterparts.

There are many shifting factors behind the prices for organic foods. Premiums for milk and eggs tend to be much higher, for example, because the government has very specific rules for what "organic" means. For example, cows producing organic milk must be allowed to graze for at least one-third of their food intake, said Jeremy Moghtader, the manager of the campus farm at the University of Michigan.

The rules "have real benefits to the animal, the consumer and environment, but they do increase the price of production," Moghtader said.

Organic and conventional vegetables are grown in similar ways, so the price difference tends to be lower. Organic farmers can save money by not using pesticides or synthetic fertilizers, but they may have to pay more for workers to pull weeds or control bugs, Moghtader said.

In this combination photo, regular ketchup is shown for sale at $3.87 per bottle and organic ketchup is shown for sale at $5.85 per bottle Jan. 16 at a grocery store in Doral, Florida.Wilfredo Lee ~ Associated Press

One reason organic premiums are falling is the increase in products on the shelves. Organics used to be confined to health-food stores and high-end groceries such as Whole Foods, but mainstream stores are increasingly offering them. Kroger, one of the nation's largest grocery chains, said it stocks 9,000 organic items in its stores and notched $1 billion in organic produce sales in 2017.

On a recent weekday, Kroger was selling Simple Truth organic orange juice -- its in-house brand -- for $3.49 for 52 fluid ounces. That was $1 more than the same size of conventional Kroger-brand orange juice, or 49 cents more than conventional Tropicana-brand orange juice.

Costco's Kirkland Signature store brand introduced organic eggs in 2007 and organic beef in 2012. Walmart's Great Value store brand sells a 15-ounce can of organic pumpkin for $1.88; that's just 10 cents more than conventional Libby's brand canned pumpkin.

Consumer demand also impacts prices. Right now, demand for organics is outpacing supply in many categories. U.S. sales of fast-moving consumer goods -- a category including food, beverages and toiletries -- were flat last year, but sales of organic goods jumped 9 percent, Nielsen said.

In this combination photo, regular large brown eggs, left, are shown for sale at $2.69 a dozen and large organic brown eggs, right, are shown for $5.29 per dozen Jan. 17 at a grocery store in Doral, Florida.Wilfredo Lee ~ Associated Press

Millennial households are leading that charge, as they stock up on organic milk and baby food for their children. But other generations are also buying more organic products. Overall, 88 percent of American households have bought organic food or beverages.

"Consumers are more focused on products that have some benefit to them," said Sarah Schmansky, a vice president of growth and strategy at Nielsen.

In some cases, organics are breathing life back into dusty grocery aisles. Sales of conventional lunchmeat and cheese at the deli counter had been weakening, since consumers didn't want to wait for them to be sliced. But buyers seeking fresh, organic options are returning to the deli. Sale of organic deli lunchmeat have risen an average of 18 percent annually over the last four years, while organic deli cheese sales are up 26 percent.

Schmansky said food scares -- such as E. coli outbreaks traced to lettuce -- are also leading some consumers to organic labels because they trust them.

In this combination photo, regular Gala apples are shown for sale at $2.49 a pound, and organic Gala apples are shown for sale at $2.99 a pound Jan. 16 at a grocery store in Doral, Florida.Wilfredo Lee ~ Associated Press

While price premiums may continue to drop, it's difficult to say whether they'll ever go away entirely, said Ryan Koory, a senior economist at Mercaris, a data firm that tracks organic agriculture.

Looser government policies and crop insurance programs better tailored to small organic farms could help lower those premiums, Koory said.

A recession could also lower consumer demand for organics, and therefore their price premiums. But if the last recession is any guide, those premiums could bounce back quickly.