Editorial

ANOTHER CHURCH-STATE FIASCO

This article comes from our electronic archive and has not been reviewed. It may contain glitches.

Public high schools more and more frequently around the nation are requiring students to perform volunteer community service as a requirement for graduation. One Chicago-area school that has had this requirement for more than 20 years is now facing a quandary: Can volunteer work at church be counted and not somehow erode separation of church and state?

The question is silly -- but not altogether unexpected in this age of hair splitting over bald issues.

Consider the ramifications: Under a tight interpretation, high school students would not be permitted to volunteer at hospitals run by religious organizations, or food pantries set up at churches or day-care center or nursing homes or anything else affiliated with a church.

Fortunately for us, churches are the backbone of charitable activities. Instilling the value of community service in high school students is commendable. But at the expense of neglecting church-sponsored efforts to do good, even if no religious dogma is being espoused?

Sometimes those who seek good intentions are blinded by folly.