Religion in public places is thorny case

When is a public monument featuring the Ten Commandments a violation of the U.S. Constitution?

The answer, according to various federal courts, depends on where you are.

Some judges have ruled such monuments in or near government buildings are OK, but other judges have ordered them removed.

Because of the conflicting rulings, there may be a good reason for the U.S Supreme Court to settle the dispute. But some legal experts wonder if the High Court would even agree to hear the case. Other experts say now is the time to try.

Pushing such a case is akin to having a contest to make a thorny decision. In such contests, a winner has to be chosen -- even if there are no good entries. If the Supreme Court agrees to decide this issue, half the country will be displeased with whatever decision it comes up with.

But if the justices are looking for guidance, we support those Americans who believe public displays of the Ten Commandments show the historical and moral context upon which the nation was founded.