- Owner of Mary Jane Burgers & Brew in Perryville to open new culinary concept in Cape (9/15/17)3
- Man accused of setting fire to Delta bar; posted photos of it burning on Facebook (9/17/17)5
- McClure man accused of leaving children in hot truck while gambling in casino (9/19/17)1
- How the story of one dog is helping others (9/14/17)1
- Eyewitnesses testify about fatal shooting; men were using drugs, alcohol (9/14/17)
- Jury finds Harris guilty of murder, 3 other counts (9/15/17)4
- Retailer may come to Jackson; rezoning needed first (9/17/17)2
- New boutique store advocates for special-needs people (9/19/17)
- Planet Fitness to anchor Town Plaza shopping center (9/18/17)1
- Mo. conservation agents help fight fires in western U.S. (9/15/17)
Yoder case isn't about consensual psychiatric care
To the editor:
In response to the articles "Psychiatry on trial" and "Millie's story: A woman's up-and-down romance with a mental patient": The reporter cast me as a love interest, but this role unfortunately precluded comments I made opposing coercive psychiatry.
In the "Psychiatry on trial" article, Dr. Chris Fichtner, chief psychiatrist of the Illinois Department of Mental Health, said it's good to be challenged by the anti-psychiatry movement. Referring to the Rodney Yoder case in the same breath as anti-psychiatry is a smear tactic to detract from the issue: Is coercive psychiatry just?
Yes, there is an anti-psychiatry movement, but these folks oppose both coercive and consensual psychiatry. Many also do not question the premise of mental illness, as the Yoder case does. In fact, the anti-psychiatry movement seeks to replace one form of coercion with another. It seeks to replace forced psychiatry with forcing taxpayers to fund what it calls "empowering alternatives" because it believes in the mythology of mental illness.
Fichtner also says he believes in mental illness. Is belief a requisite for evidence? For example, a doctor would never say he believes in diabetes. There is no need to assert belief, because there is objective physical evidence diabetes exists -- unlike so-called mental illness.
Yoder's case does not in any way represent to diminish, refuse or restrict people their right to consensual psychiatry and its various treatments. The Yoder case represents the movement to abolish forced psychiatry.
Vancouver, British Columbia