Recruiting efforts rise for women in construction
NEW YORK -- Janice Moreno graduated from college with a degree in English literature but never landed a job paying more than $12 an hour.
Now, at 36, she's back in the classroom -- in safety glasses and a T-shirt -- learning how to be a carpenter.
"I anticipate a lot of hard work," she said amid instruction in sawing techniques. "I believe it's going to pay off."
If Moreno's six-week training program in New York City leads to a full-time job, she'll have bucked long odds. On this Labor Day weekend, ponder the latest federal data: About 7.1 million Americans were employed in construction-related occupations last year -- and only 2.6 percent were women.
That percentage has hardly budged since the 1970s, while women have made gains in many other fields. Even in firefighting -- where they historically were unwelcome -- women comprise a greater share of the workforce, at 3.5 percent.
Why the low numbers, in an industry abounding with high-paying jobs that don't require a degree? Reasons include a dearth of recruitment efforts aimed at women and hard-to-quash stereotypes that construction work doesn't suit them.
Another factor, according to a report by the National Women's Law Center, is denigration and sexual harassment of women at work sites.
"It's not surprising that the construction trades are sometimes called 'the industry time forgot,"' said Fatima Goss Graves, the center's vice president for education and employment. "It's time for this industry to enter the modern era -- to expand apprenticeships and training opportunities for women, hire qualified female workers and enforce a zero-tolerance policy against sexual harassment."
Efforts to accomplish those goals are more advanced in New York than in many parts of the country, with pledges by unions, employers and city officials to boost women's share of construction jobs. One key player is Nontraditional Employment for Women, a not-for-profit which for three decades has offered training programs such as the one taken by Moreno.
Known as NEW, the organization has arrangements with unions to take women directly into their multiyear apprenticeships -- at a starting wage of about $17, plus benefits -- once they finish training. After four or five years, they can attain journeyman status, with hourly pay of $40 or more.
Kathleen Culhane, NEW's interim president, said more than 1,000 graduates of the program have obtained apprenticeships since 2005, and women comprise 12 percent to 15 percent of the apprentices with leading laborers' and carpenters' unions in the city.
Thanks to support from foundations, employers and government contracts, NEW covers all costs for the women taking its programs, including transit fares to and from the headquarters in Manhattan. Students must have high school or GED diplomas and carry 50-pound loads.
On a recent class day, Moreno and about 20 other students learned carpentry techniques from 67-year-old Howie Rotz, who's been teaching since retiring eight years ago.
"Women have a good work ethic," he said. "They're very serious."
Another instructor, Kathleen Klohe, worked as a roofer and a unionized carpenter before joining NEW after the recession hit in 2008.
"Did I come across sex discrimination? Once or twice," she said. "A few times, I got the sense that I was not wanted, but I kept on. I knew what I was doing."
She encourages students' interest in construction while advising it requires "a certain mental strength."
Beyond learning job skills, NEW students do role-playing to get ready for challenges in dealing with co-workers. Among the topics, Moreno said, is how to distinguish between flagrant sexual harassment that should be reported, as opposed to less egregious behavior that perhaps should be endured.
"They want us to be prepared for the possibility we won't be liked, or we'll be the only woman on the job," Moreno said. "If you complain too quickly, your job can be at risk."
A role model
If young women considering a construction career need a role model, Holley Thomas might fit the bill.
She took up welding at a community college in Alabama, landed a job in 2009 with construction giant KBR Inc. and in 2010 became the first woman to take first place in welding at the Associated Builders and Contractors' National Craft Championships -- a competition dating to 1987.
Thomas, 29, has worked her way up to foreman and supervises a 10-worker welding crew at a KBR project in West Palm Beach, Florida. She speaks occasionally to high school girls, who are impressed by her paycheck that averages more than $2,000 a week and what she calls "my toys" -- a Harley-Davidson, a Mustang and a Jeep Wrangler.
Thomas knows harassment exists within the construction industry but said she's experienced none at KBR. She's impressed by the efforts of some companies to recruit more women and minorities, though the pace is slower than she'd like.
"The biggest issue is getting through to the parents of the kids, the counselors at the schools and making clear that construction is a viable career," she said.
From an older generation, Mary Battle also has succeeded with a construction career, although she says it required tough-mindedness.
Now 50, Battle has worked in cement masonry for 30 years and in 2012 became the first woman elected as business manager of Plasterers and Cement Masons Local 891 in Washington, D.C. Under her leadership, the number of women in the local has risen from five to 12, but she doesn't believe most construction unions are committed to boosting the ranks of women.
"Men don't perceive of women as someone coming to work; they perceive of women as a sex object," Battle said. "I set rules from the beginning: 'Don't touch me.' You have to be prepared to set a man in his place."
For younger women considering a construction career, Battle tells them: "The job is not physically hard; it's mentally hard.
"No matter how much negativity you get, keep on the job and don't quit -- that's my motto," she said.
Battle, a mother of six, credits a devoted baby sitter with helping her cope with the long hours she sometimes faced as a mason. Many construction jobs start in early morning, and it can be crucial for mothers in the workforce -- especially single moms -- to arrange for early-morning child care. Mothers also can find it difficult to accept temporary jobs requiring lengthy travel from their homes.
Another challenge, for women who complete apprenticeships, is to get assigned their fair share of working hours. It's a problem big enough to drive some women out of the field, according to Elly Spicer, who worked for 11 years as a carpenter and is director of training at a technical college affiliated with New York City carpenters unions.
"You'll find, unquestionably, that women get access to less hours than men, even though they get same wages and benefits," said Spicer, 57. "You can't do this working six months of the year."
Spicer said she mostly was treated with respect during her carpentry career in the 1980s and '90s, but she knew of other women who quit because of constant pressure to prove themselves.
"Every crew was different," she said. "You could have an enlightened foreman, while another might be patronizing. You still find that variation today -- good old sexism still rears its ugly head sometimes."
'Desperate to hire'
The management side of the construction industry insists it would welcome more women.
"Most of our members are desperate to hire people," said Brian Turmail, public affairs director for the Associated General Contractors of America. "They're looking for any candidate who's qualified to come and join the team -- women, minorities, veterans."
Turmail suggested most women aren't tempted by construction careers, while those who are interested might be hampered by a nationwide cutback in school-based vocational programs.
"It's not a question of folks not wanting women -- it's women not wanting to work in construction," he said. "We would love to see the numbers change. It's the right thing to do, and we really need the people."
Turmail's association and many of its chapters across the country are undertaking educational campaigns and recruiting programs aimed at diversifying the construction workforce. Similar initiatives are being pushed by the National Center for Construction Education and Research, which assists employers with workforce development programs.
Jennifer Wilkerson, the center's marketing director, said the best recruiters of women are other women who've succeeded in the field. They can speak in detail about the many construction specialties -- such as welding and crane-operating -- that women can master.
"A lot of times, we think of heavy lifting -- the labor side of it -- but that doesn't represent the full spectrum of jobs," Wilkerson said. "Once women know there's a place for them, and something they really can do well, they love it."
The Department of Labor is stepping up its involvement with plans to award $100 million in grants this year for apprenticeship programs that expand opportunities for women and minorities. Some of the grants targeting women call for providing child-care assistance.
"The reality is that the face of apprenticeship in the construction industry has been white male," Labor Secretary Thomas Perez said. "We're working to ensure the future reflects the face of America."
A crucial step, Perez said, is to raise awareness about the dearth of women in construction, and to highlight the successes of the relatively small number of women who've thrived in the sector.
"Women are good at this," he said. "They've punched a ticket to the middle class and speak with great pride of the barriers they've overcome. They are the pioneers, and they want the cavalry to come."
Among those impatient with the slow pace of change is Susan Eisenberg, a resident artist/scholar at Brandeis University who worked as a construction industry electrician for 15 years, starting in 1978. She published an acclaimed book in 1998, "We'll Call You If We Need You," based on her interviews with other women in construction.
Eisenberg has argued women's share of the construction workforce should be far higher -- perhaps 25 percent instead of 2.6 percent.
"It's out of step with so much of what's going on," she said. "Women are now much more physically fit than my generation. They're 15 percent of the military."
Eisenberg suggests both management and unions should try harder to recruit women. And she said government agencies could improve the situation with tougher enforcement of anti-discrimination policies.
"People who think they will be held accountable will change," she said.
Under current conditions, she said, women may be accepted as apprentices but cut short their careers because of discrimination.
"We've moved from a closed door to a revolving door," Eisenberg said.
In the recent National Women's Law Center report, New Yorker Patricia Valoy, who studied construction management and engineering at Columbia University, described sustained harassment she encountered during a construction apprenticeship.
"Men would stop their work to stare and wolf whistle," Valoy said. "On a few occasions, I got called a 'bitch' for refusing to reply to inappropriate remarks. ... I worked on the site for a year until the stress of constantly being harassed, belittled and intimidated was not worth the effort."
The Labor Department is aware of the harassment problem, and its Office of Federal Contract Compliance Programs has pledged to crack down on federal contractors who fail to prevent serious abuses.
"Ending blatant discrimination that excludes women from working in construction and increasing their representation in the industry is long overdue," wrote Donna Lenhoff, compliance office's senior civil rights adviser, in a blog post.
In one case, the office determined three female carpenters with a Puerto Rico construction company were sexually harassed, subjected to retaliation and denied work hours comparable to those of their male counterparts. At times, the company failed to provide the women with a restroom, and they had to relieve themselves outdoors, the office said.
Under a conciliation agreement, the company agreed to pay $40,000 to the three workers and develop anti-harassment policies.
In another case, involving L&M Construction of Capitol Heights, Maryland, investigators found pervasive sexual harassment, including lewd acts, sexual gestures, and propositions directed at female employees. The federal office said the company unlawfully fired nine employees, including several men, for opposing the hostile work environment at sites. The company agreed to pay back wages to the fired workers and pay for an assessment of its employment and anti-harassment policies.
Statistically, it appears that progress is being made. Construction consistently rates among the top 10 employment sectors with the most sexual-harassment allegations filed with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, but the numbers have declined in recent years -- from 416 in 1999 to 132 in 2012.
"I love my trade very much. I love watching nothing become something," union leader Mary Battle told the National Women's Law Center. "They'll harass and belittle you ... But we must stick with it, or else things won't ever get better for women on the job."
Follow David Crary on Twitter at http://twitter.com/CraryAP
More to explore
Cape Chamber supports tax extensionThe Cape Girardeau Area Chamber of Commerce board of directors has voted to support an upcoming quarter-cent capital improvement sales tax (CIST) ballot issue on Aug. 6. The chamber board's vote to support the tax measure took place July 12 but was...
Illinois faces 'uphill battle' for disaster declaration for Flood of 2019As floodwaters begin to recede in southern Illinois, the price tag for fighting the flood and repairing damage to roads and other public infrastructure in Alexander County is projected to total more than $5.49 million. That's the latest estimate...
Former Leopold supt. Kinder to join Jackson schools; iPad delivery among first tasksA 1993 graduate of Jackson High School has returned to serve as an associate superintendent in the Jackson R-2 School District, and one of his first jobs will be to distribute hundreds of iPads and laptop computers to some of the district's youngest...
Cape residents reminisce about south side store that was razed this weekThe store at 1007 South Sprigg has operated under a variety of names, but for many South Cape Girardeau residents, only one name comes to mind -- Ratliff's Grocery. For the first time in over 75 years, the property now stands empty. As demolition of...
Most read 7/18/19Ask a foodie: Mudcat Coffeehouse offers tasty hope to low carb seekersYou may have noticed my focus on food has shifted a bit since I started writing this column last year: more salads, more color, less fried and sugary things. The truth is I simply can't eat whatever I want anymore. Being recently diagnosed as...
Former NASA astronaut Linda Godwin remembers moon landing, recalls space flightsFifty years ago this Saturday, man landed on the moon, and the country is celebrating the milestone. Former NASA astronaut Linda Godwin of Jackson said she still sees the mission as "quite an accomplishment." People understood the physics to travel...
Officials look for compromise on Center JunctionIf there was one thing everyone at the Southeast Metropolitan Planning Organization (SEMPO) meeting Wednesday could agree on, it was you can't please everybody. "But we're looking for a solution everyone can live with," said Missouri Department of...
Committee members identify pool prioritiesCape Girardeau's proposed indoor aquatic center needs to include a 50-meter competition pool and a separate recreational pool, as well as a diving well, an advisory committee concluded Wednesday. Committee members at the meeting, held at the Cape...
Photo Gallery 7/18/19Daddy Daughter Tea Party at the Jackson Civic CenterDisney princesses, live violinists, fingernail stations, a photo booth and coloring activities were provided for entertainment at a Daddy Daughter Tea Party hosted by Chick-Fil-A on Thursday, July 18, 2019, at the Jackson Civic Center.
Most read 7/17/19Trump is wrong to constantly attack othersAt lunch the other day, a good friend of mine explained he stays away from the national news, and he's all the happier for it. He no longer watches the cable news channels, and he's deleted all but one of the national newspaper apps he used to have...
Former Cape councilman John Voss to run for House seat, setting up GOP battleFormer Cape Girardeau City Council member John Voss will run for a state House seat, setting up a Republican primary battle next year with state Sen. Wayne Wallingford. Voss announced his candidacy Tuesday in an emailed news release. Voss said his...
Faith compels new facility for homeless in CapeOn any given night, the Rev. Renita Green says there are a dozen or so homeless men living on the streets in Cape Girardeau. “When I say ‘on the street,’ I mean sometimes they tent, sometimes they sleep in bathrooms, some wedge themselves into...
Red Jumpsuit Apparatus, Lucero to headline 55-band Fawkesfest19 in CapeHomegrown multi-day music festival Fawkesfest19 is joining forces with American rock band The Red Jumpsuit Apparatus in support of the Honorable Young Men Club and Safe House for Women on Aug. 30 and 31 in downtown Cape Girardeau. Justin Aden,...
Kelly welcomes new school district superintendentBENTON, Mo. — Nearly 100 people turned out to meet Scott County “Kelly” School District’s new superintendent during a welcome reception Sunday in the high school gymnasium. After he was introduced by Kelly School Board president David Brashear,...
Southbound I-55 in Scott County reduced for bridge workSouthbound Interstate 55 in Scott County will be reduced to one lane as Missouri Department of Transportation crews perform maintenance to the bridge at mile marker 80 in Benton, Missouri. According to the MoDOT news release, the work will be done...
Flood of 2019 sets record for durationThe Mississippi River at Cape Girardeau has set a record. Today marks the 126th consecutive day the river has exceeded flood stage, breaking the previous mark of 125 days set between June 10 and Oct. 12, 1993, according to the U.S. Army Corps of...
Cape city board nixes road projects from funding listA Cape Girardeau committee developing a list of transportation-sales-tax projects has removed one proposed Veterans Memorial Drive project from consideration while keeping extension of another section of the street on the list for now. ...
Cape Council defends decision to hire consultant for aquatic projectCape Girardeau City Council members defended their decision Monday to hire a second consultant to plan for a new, indoor aquatic center. Ward 1 Councilman Daniel Presson said “people get tired” of hearing about the city hiring consultants. Ward 5...
Jackson Aldermen approve medical-marijuana zoning, move forward on sewer extensionZoning for medical-marijuana businesses in Jackson was approved Monday night by the city's Board of Aldermen, but only after two Jackson residents asked the aldermen that the buffer zone between those businesses and any existing schools, churches...
Most read 7/15/19Business Notebook: Coming to Cape: Custom cutlery, flavorful food, health-care hackingAside from Southeast Missouri State University's River Campus, there hasn't been a great deal of development along Morgan Oak Street in the past decade or so. Once a heavily-traveled avenue that led to the old Mississippi River bridge, Morgan Oak...
Waterlogged East Cape bracing for remnants of Tropical Depression BarryThe remnants of Tropical Depression Barry will bring heavy rain to parts of Southeast Missouri and Southern Illinois from Monday morning through Tuesday evening, according to a Sunday afternoon alert from the National Weather Service. The alert...
Rick Horton: ‘Our effort is not only just about success’After a video of baseball days gone by, former St. Louis Cardinals pitcher Rick Horton gave a talk reinforcing the idea everyone has a “purpose and destiny” during the sixth annual Semoball Awards on Saturday at the River Campus. Horton, who is...
Telescopes, fishing poles and more: Library loans out much more than booksLending fishing poles with full tackle boxes, telescopes — and soon binoculars — are part of Riverside Regional Library’s initiative to welcome new faces who may not be aware there is more to discover beyond the walls of its six branches. Jackson...
Jackson Board of Aldermen agenda 7/15/19Public hearing n Hearing to consider amendments to Chapter 65 of the Code of Ordinances, regarding the addition of medical marijuana dispensing, manufacturing, cultivation and testing facilities as uses in specified zoning districts and establishing...
MoDOT changes course on center junction closureMissouri Department of Transportation (MoDOT) engineers have shifted gears and now are looking to keep traffic flowing on U.S. 61 during construction of an Interstate 55 interchange between Cape Girardeau and Jackson. MoDOT officials, including...
Saint Francis to forbid physicians from medical marijuana certification; SoutheastHEALTH 'exploring' subjectCiting a federal prohibition against marijuana, Saint Francis Healthcare System says it will not allow its affiliated physicians to become certified to prescribe medical cannabis. Meanwhile, SoutheastHEALTH is exploring the issue as health care...
Deeper dive: Cape council, committee to hire second consultant for aquatic center projectThe Cape Girardeau City Council looks to hire another consultant Monday to help plan for a new, indoor aquatic center even as an advisory committee offers up an expansive list of what could be included in the project. City staff has recommended...
Most read 7/12/19Oran celebrates 150th with two-day celebrationOran, Missouri, turns 150 years old July 16. To commemorate, the town is hosting a two-day celebration with food, games, tours and a full entertainment lineup at Tilles Memorial City Park July 19 and 20. To kick things off, a non-denominational...
Most read 7/12/19Cape Council rewards city manager with 'reasonable' pay raisenote: with fact box showing Meyer's salary to jackson city administrator and county commissioners Cape Girardeau city manager Scott Meyer was rewarded with a $3,155 pay raise for the new fiscal year that began July 1, which one councilman called...