Marketplace
![[SeMissourian.com]](http://www.semissourian.com/images/nameplate.gif)
|
|
Fair ~ River stage: 25.3 Falling Friday, July 3, 2009 |
RSS
 Print
 Email link
 Respond to editor
 Read comments (4)
 Share link
Mo. Sen. Koster visits city firefighters in campaign for attorney general postFriday, August 1, 2008
Koster came to Cape Girardeau, not usually a stronghold for Democrats, on Thursday for what his campaign billed as a "Roundtable Discussion with First Responders and Workers Regarding the Important Partnership between Local Communities and the Attorney General's Office." He drew three people, all Cape Girardeau firefighters, including two of the leaders of Local 1084 of the International Association of Firefighters, to the event at VFW Post 3838. That didn't deter Koster, who chatted with Dean Lynn, president of the local, and Randy Sander, the treasurer, about topics ranging from collective bargaining rights for public employees to enforcing prevailing wage laws and dealing with employers who use illegal immigrant labor. Koster asked the union leaders to spread the word to fellow firefighters that their statewide organization, along with many other union groups, have endorsed him in the hotly contested race. Koster, a first-term lawmaker and former Cass County prosecuting attorney, faces state Reps. Jeff Harris of Columbia and Margaret Donnelly of St. Louis, along with Kansas City schoolteacher Molly Williams, in the Tuesday primary. The winner will face state Sen. Mike Gibbons, who is unopposed in the Republican primary, in the November election. Worker rights Koster began the conversation with the firefighters by asking whether a 2007 Missouri Supreme Court decision had changed their relationship with the city. In that decision, the court ruled that all workers, whether employed by public entities or private companies, are guaranteed collective bargaining rights under the Missouri Constitution. The ruling addressed worker rights but did not detail the responsibilities of public entities under the law. Missouri has made the issue of formal contracts and negotiations voluntary for local governments, requiring only that representatives "meet and confer" with union representatives. The ruling hasn't changed the way the union is treated by city leaders, Sander said. "We give them a letter, then they laugh and say this is what we are going to do." Koster replied that he expects additional court cases to define the rules more completely. "The Supreme Court has cracked the door open, and what happens next is really interesting," Koster said. "It seems to be that a court will add branches to this tree." Koster's opponents have sought to make points by focusing on his switch late in 2007 from the Republican to the Democratic Party and more recently filed complaints with the Missouri Ethics Commission over his campaign finances. Koster has been accused of stepping over the limits of state campaign finance law by working to gather large contributions passed through local political party committees. Koster said he expects to be cleared by the commission and is using techniques used repeatedly by Republicans and Democrats to finance their campaigns. Koster said he has three goals as Missouri attorney general — combating Medicaid fraud, which he said consumes 10 percent of Missouri's $6 billion annual Medicaid budget; enforcing prevailing wage laws that require public works projects pay wages at or above the rates in private construction; and to create a new division in the office that will focus on enforcing antidiscrimination laws on behalf of women, the disabled and minorities. 335-6611, extension 126 Comments  Note: The nature of the Internet makes it impractical for our staff to review every comment. If you feel that a comment is offensive, please Login or Create an account first, and then you will be able to flag a comment as objectionable. Please also note that those who post comments on semissourian.com may do so using a screen name, which may or may not reflect a website user's actual name. Readers should be careful not to assign comments to real people who may have names similar to screen names. Refrain from obscenity in your comments, and to keep discussions civil, don't say anything in a way your grandmother would be ashamed to read.
|
|
del.icio.us
Digg
StumbleUpon
Technorati
Newsvine
Facebook
Furl
Reddit
Google
That is all we need...mandated contracts with employees to drive our taxes up even higher.
Maybe this gives you an idea of why he drew three people to his event.
Attorney general candidate Koster used staff to channel money
By DAVID A. LIEB • Associated Press Writer • July 8, 2008
Read Comments(1)Recommend (3)Print this page E-mail this article
Share this article: Del.icio.us Facebook Digg Reddit Newsvine What’s this?
JEFFERSON CITY, Mo. (AP) — They met at an Italian restaurant in southwest Missouri. A campaign aide for Democratic attorney general candidate Chris Koster and the treasurer for a local Democratic committee. The purpose: a check exchange.
Koster's aide handed the Democratic official a check from an innocuous-sounding group called the Economic Growth Council, along with a pair of letters she had created - one from the Economic Growth Council accompanying its money, the other from Koster's campaign soliciting money from the local political committee.
The letters were formalities. The Democratic official provided Koster's aide a pair of checks similar in size to the amount she had received.
Just like that, Koster's campaign channeled nearly $27,000 to itself - part of the roughly $450,000 from big-time donors that got routed around campaign contribution limits to Koster in a three-month period.
E-mail communications obtained by The Associated Press show Koster's campaign staff helped direct donors wishing to give more than the state limit to the Economic Growth Council, then coordinated the transfer of that money to local political party committees and onto Koster's campaign - a potential violation of an 8-year-old ruling against such orchestration.
The documents were provided to the AP by someone close to Koster's campaign on the condition of anonymity, because the person is not authorized to speak for the campaign.
Koster defends his fundraising tactics as legal - and similar to those being used by other major statewide candidates.
But it's unclear whether other campaign staffs have been so deeply involved in coordinating the money shuffling. A former Koster campaign aide now is concerned the tactics may have been illegal.
Officials at the Missouri Ethics Commission are reluctant to say publicly whether fundraising scenarios such as Koster's violate campaign finance laws, in case they later are asked to make a ruling.
But "that's getting awfully close," said former Ethics Commission executive director Bob Connor, who remains on staff at the commission. "That could come before the commission if somebody thought it was improper."
The Ethics Commission historically has granted candidates considerable leeway. For example, regulators have said candidates can both raise money for other political committees and solicit contributions from those committees.
But in a 2000 opinion that remains in effect today, the Missouri Ethics Commission said candidates cannot request that contributions be made to other political committees "with the express purpose of passing those contributions through the committee to the candidate."
Koster said his actions are within the bounds of that decision.
"I strongly believe - because we have acted in consultation with the law, the rulings and on the advise of the ethics commission - that we are in line with campaign finance laws," Koster said in an interview at his Jefferson City campaign headquarters.
Koster is facing state Reps. Margaret Donnelly and Jeff Harris in the Aug. 5 Democratic attorney general primary. The winner may no longer have to worry about campaign contribution limits, because a bill pending before Gov. Matt Blunt would repeal them effective Aug. 28.
A state senator and former Cass County prosecutor, Koster is a prolific fundraiser who switched from the Republican to Democratic party shortly before he announced his attorney general's candidacy in fall 2007.
Like other statewide candidates, Koster reaped five- and six-figure contributions while Missouri's donation limits were temporarily lifted during the first half of 2007. After the Missouri Supreme Court reinstated the limits, Koster joined other statewide candidates in refunding all donations above the retroactively reinstated maximum of $1,275.
For Koster, that meant returning about $370,000. His refunds checks were dated Dec. 17. The next day, the Economic Growth Council was created with the Ethics Commission by Chuck Hatfield, a former top aide to Democratic Attorney General Jay Nixon. Koster had befriended Hatfield in law school and later served as the best man in Hatfield's wedding.
Hatfield said the creation of the Economic Growth Council was his own idea.
About 70 percent of Koster's Christmastime refunds were re-donated to the Economic Growth Council, including $125,000 from stem-cell research supporter James Stowers and $17,450 from Ameristar casinos. The point man for both donors was lobbyist Jorgen Schlemeier.
So why give to Hatfield's committee?
"The treasurer at the Economic Growth Council made a very clear statement that we're founded to help Chris Koster out," Schlemeier said.
Through the first three months of 2008, the council reported receiving $493,825 from various donors, nearly all of which was routed to Koster.
The council directly gave Koster the maximum $1,350. Much of the rest made its way to Koster by first passing through local political party committees, which can give almost 20 times the amount toward candidates as individuals, businesses and interest groups.
On March 19, then-Koster campaign staffer Susan McNay sent en e-mail to Hatfield with the names of 29 local political committees and the amounts of money each was to receive from the Economic Growth Council. Hatfield responded that he would write the checks.
McNay, who has since left Koster's campaign, said Koster asked her to deliver the Economic Growth Council checks to the local political party committees so that she could exchange them for contributions to Koster's campaign. In several cases, McNay acknowledged, she also used her Koster campaign computer to create a memo bearing Hatfield's name on Economic Growth Council letterhead that accompanied the checks to the political committees.
Koster said he was unaware McNay used campaign equipment to create Economic Growth Council documents, though McNay said she had informed Koster of what she was doing.
In essence, McNay was working for the Economic Growth Council - driving thousands of miles around the state as a check courier - while being paid by Koster's campaign.
"I trusted the candidate, even though I had questions about whether we were doing something that was not right," McNay said. "He assured me everything was fine, and now I have concerns that we broke the law."
On March 25, for example, McNay met Shelby County Clerk Tracy Smith outside a northern Missouri courthouse to hand over a $2,550 check to the 18th Senatorial District Democratic Committee of which Smith is treasurer. In exchange, McNay received a $2,350 check to Koster's campaign.
The next day, about 330 miles to the southwest, McNay met Jasper County Democratic Chairwoman Susan DeCarlo at an Italian restaurant in Joplin. It was the second time she had delivered a $13,750 check for the 129th Legislative District Democratic Committee of which DeCarlo is treasurer. McNay left the restaurant with a pair of $13,450 checks - one a direct contribution to Koster, the other an indirect contribution made payable to Koster's advertising buyer, LUC Media of Marietta, Ga.
Koster contends other campaigns also routinely use staffers to shuttle and flip checks through political committees, though he cited no one specifically by name. Hatfield also defended it as legal, adding: "This level of coordination with campaigns is not unusual."
Koster pointed to a July 2004 Ethics Commission decision rejecting a complaint alleging Democratic Gov. Bob Holden had violated campaign finance laws. In that case, a volunteer for Holden had delivered a check from the Missouri Democratic Party to a local political committee, which then gave her a check for Holden.
Perhaps the most comparable situation to Koster's is that of Republican gubernatorial candidate Sarah Steelman. Two wholesome-sounding committees - Power to the People and the Committee for Common Sense Values - contributed more than $120,000 during the first three months of the year to various local political party committees, which passed the money onto Steelman.
But Steelman spokesman Spence Jackson said he is unaware of anyone on Steelman's campaign staff personally delivering and picking up the checks.
Nixon, a Democrat, and Republican Kenny Hulshof both also have received dollars that flowed from their state party committees through local political committees to their gubernatorial campaigns. But spokesmen for Nixon and Hulshof both denied campaign staff ever had been involved in shuffling those checks from one committee to the next.
I'm surprised he only drew 3 people to his event. After all he is a republican who just happened to change his political affiliation for personal gain. Maybe he should have still claimed he was a republican as he advertised his Cape visit.
His campaign financing practices are, if not illegal, at the minimum dirty.
Koster may have told you that the complaints were filed by his opponents but it isn't true. One complaint was filed by a bipartisan group that included the Democratic Senate Minority, a Republican state senator and some attorney that I can't remember the name of. I am not sure who filed the other complaint but I don't think there is any evidence it was filed by his opponents.