- Cape teacher accused of assaulting student at football game (10/23/16)41
- Pedestrian killed during traffic collision on I-55 (10/23/16)9
- Scott County Sheriff Rick Walter faces challenge from criminal investigator Wes Drury (10/21/16)8
- Shooting injures two people in Cape early Tuesday (10/19/16)34
- 18-year-old killed in one-car crash Thursday morning (10/21/16)1
- Man arrested after dispute at school spurs brief lockdown (10/21/16)6
- 'I feel for them' (10/20/16)1
- Hundreds turn out for VintageNOW fundraiser (10/23/16)3
- Crews are working on the new Drury Hotel (10/21/16)4
- Benton man accused of statutory rape, selling pot (10/20/16)1
O'Connor would find analogy blasphemous
To the editor:
I was intrigued by Paul Greenberg's claim of Flannery O'Connor as his champion for banning flag burning. O'Connor would find his analogy between her belief in the "real presence" in the Eucharist and his belief in "presence" -- the presence of what he never makes clear -- in the American flag far more offensive than her companion's view that it was only a "symbol." She would have found Greenberg's abuse of her faith blasphemous.
The "real presence" of Christ in the Eucharist is a matter of religious faith. The claim that the Bible is more than a book is a matter of religious faith. Greenberg must use religious analogies for his claim that the flag is more than a symbol and that it has "presence," for this too is a matter of religious faith. His concept of "presence" lies behind all image-based religions.
Greenberg is entitled to worship his red, white and blue graven image, for our country guarantees freedom of religion. The flag serves well as the icon of the cult of civil religion. However, a law banning flag burning because of its religious "presence" would violate the Constitution, for it would establish a protected religion. As a Christian I can respect Greenberg's faith beliefs, but I cannot participate in the worship of his images. I can respect the flag as a symbol, but if it claims religious "presence," then I must say, in the words of Flannery O'Connor, "to hell with it."
KERRY H. WYNN
Cape Girardeau, Mo.