Controversial call plays on ALCS' open day

Friday, October 14, 2005

CHICAGO -- Ah, an off day in the AL championship series, a chance for the Angels and White Sox to take a little break out West.

But everyone else in baseball was still buzzing -- not about a long home run or splendid pitching performance. Instead, all the chatter centered on the confusing call Wednesday night that helped decide Game 2 in Chicago.

Strike three on A.J. Pierzynski in the bottom of the ninth inning has already been replayed over and over. And it'll be scrutinized, dissected and debated for years to come -- especially if the White Sox get past the Angels and reach the World Series for the first time since 1959.

"One of the most bizarre plays I've ever been a part of," said Pierzynski, who caused all the chaos by simply hustling to first base.

Given a second chance when plate umpire Doug Eddings called strike three -- but not the third out -- the White Sox beat Los Angeles 2-1 on Joe Crede's two-out double in the ninth to even the best-of-seven ALCS at a game apiece.

Moments earlier, third-string catcher Josh Paul and his Angels teammates ran off the field, certain they were headed to extra innings.

In a sequence as strange as any seen on a baseball field, Pierzynski swung at and missed a low pitch from Los Angeles reliever Kelvim Escobar, appearing to end the ninth inning with the score tied at 1.

The ball was gloved by Paul -- replays appeared to show he caught it cleanly just before it would have hit the dirt. And behind him, Eddings clearly raised his right arm and closed his fist, signaling strike three.

Still, Pierzynski whirled around and ran to first -- just in case. Positive the inning was over, Paul rolled the ball out to the mound with the Angels already coming off the field, so Pierzynski was easily safe.

"He called him out, and that's what's disappointing," said Angels manager Mike Scioscia, who certainly has a justifiable gripe. "When he rings him up with a fist, he's out."

Not this time.

Scioscia argued, the umpires conferred -- twice -- and the call stood after a delay of about five minutes.

And, as if it were destined to end this way, pinch-runner Pablo Ozuna quickly stole second before Crede lined an 0-2 pitch into the left-field corner for a game-winning double.

That left the umpires right where they don't want to be -- in the middle of a postseason dispute. Eddings said all the right things after the game, he just didn't sound so sure of himself.

"I didn't have him catching the ball," said Eddings, a major league ump since 1999 who is working his third postseason assignment.

That said, plate umpires are trained to shout "no catch!" or something to indicate the ball is in play. Eddings was silent.

Maybe instant replay could have helped. Baseball took a look at going high-tech last November, but put aside the topic after general managers split a 15-15 vote on whether to keep exploring the subject.

The NFL, NBA, NHL and now nearly every major college football conference all use some form of replay. Baseball commissioner Bud Selig has said he is against it and can veto any proposal by anyone to give it a try.

Even the upsetting loss Wednesday night didn't change Scioscia's mind.

"I'm not in favor of replay at all," he said.

And because it was a judgment call, there was nothing Scioscia could've done at the time, either.

"No, it's not protestable. He's saying he didn't call him out," the manager said.

Game 3 is today in Anaheim, with John Lackey scheduled to pitch against Chicago's Jon Garland. Tired from all their overnight travel lately, the Angels planned to skip the conventional off-day workout Thursday in their own ballpark, choosing instead to let their players rest.

Eddings probably won't have a quiet time the next time out. He's scheduled to work the right-field line in Game 3 -- with the low-slung wall in Anaheim, he's sure to hear it from the Angels fans.

In the meantime, baseball has another October argument on its hands -- reminiscent of Reggie Jackson not budging in the baseline during the 1978 World Series, Don Denkinger blowing a big call that cost the Cardinals in '85, Kent Hrbek lifting Ron Gant off first base in '91 and 12-year-old Jeffrey Maier reaching over the right-field wall in the 1996 ALCS.

And these playoffs, now missing the Yankees, Red Sox, Barry Bonds or any famous "curses," suddenly offer plenty to talk about.

Respond to this story

Posting a comment requires free registration: