|
|
Fair ~ River stage: 35.66 Falling Sunday, November 8, 2009 |
|
Angel Food Ministries, etc.
Posted Sunday, November 4, 2007, at 1:14 AM<< Previous | Read comments | Respond | Email link | Next >>
I have a bunch of information to post. Before getting into details that I couldn't fit into the space in the paper, here's a quick summary of the issue at hand:
On Monday, Cape Girardeau City Council has a public hearing scheduled for Christ Church of the Heartland's special-use permit request. While the hearing is formally scheduled for 7 p.m., much of the background on this will happen at the study session, which is at 5 p.m. The study session is not televised, and is a less-formal, less-scripted information session than the meeting itself. If anyone is interested in understanding the finer points of municipal decision-making, this should provide a good example. Here's a quick breakdown of this one item on an agenda that has more than two dozen entries. Main issue: Whether a Cape Girardeau church may have a special-use permit to sell low-cost groceries from its 720 Bertling St. address, which is in a residential zone. The sides: * The church: Christ Church of the Heartland is a regional distributor for the food, a ministry that dates back four years. * The neighbors: Their complaints about retail-style grocery sales are part of an ongoing feud over traffic and noise at the church. * The planning and zoning commission: On Oct. 10, the board unanimously denied the church's special-use permit request to continue selling groceries, while praising the food program and suggesting it be moved to a commercial zone. * The city council and mayor: Have the option of overriding planning and zoning's recommendation. The church has received an offer of representation by a Texas law firm if that does not happen. One statement that's often mentioned is that no church making Angel Food Ministries sales has faced a zoning issue. This is not so. The city is currently researching more than 350 Angel Food distribution sites in Missouri to find any cases. Here is a fact: The borough of Howard, Penn., faced this same issue in 2006, after the Howard Christian Church became an Angel Food Ministries distributor. The program drew hundreds of people from up to 20 miles away, according to Howard code zoning officer Dan Brownson, creating a traffic hazard and drawing complaints from some of its 700 residents. Because the church "is in an area zoned residential," Brownson said, borough officials gave a "variance for conditional use." He said the church "acknowledged that it actually was retail because they receive a dollar from every deal they sold." The borough gave the church a permit. End of that story, no threat of a lawsuit. Since no one I've interviewed regarding the operation at 720 Bertling St. has a problem with feeding the poor or hungry, what is going on here in Cape Girardeau? Several of the neighbors living on streets around Christ Church of the Heartland are clearly unhappy about the ongoing lack of communication by the church as well as its ambitious expansion project. (More about what you can and can't do on your own property in a future blog.) In 2006, the church began construction on a parking lot and building addition to provide room for 2,000. (Basically, the building will be twice the size of Osage Community Centre.) Last month, the Revs. Zack and Diane Strong walked me through the partially finished addition, which features a series of classrooms, a large theater-style worship space for young people, a game room, restrooms and a kitchen area. The construction noise, dust, traffic and drainage problems upset neighbors. When neighbors learned the church wanted to start a day care center -- about the time I came to town -- they protested. Rev. Strong appeared at a meeting and withdrew his request for a special use permit. Neighbors complained about traffic problems with the hundreds of orders being picked up during the Angel Food distribution day and the city once again got involved. The planning and zoning commission unanimously denied the church's request for a special-use permit to continue selling the groceries, based on a single word: retail. A retail operation belongs in a commercial zone. But the church is in an area zoned for residential. (An aside: Cape has four levels of residential zoning: R-4 is for multifamily areas, such as apartments; R-3 is for two-family homes; R-2 and R-1 are for single family homes. The church is in an R-1 zone.) Basically the commissioners said Angel Food is a great program, but the church needs to do it in a commercial zone. Rev. Strong told me he has since had several offers for alternate sites, but "that's not the issue." He says his church spearheads the program and provides the volunteers, so it's staying at 720 Bertling St. Readers have posted questions on previous related stories asking why the city doesn't simply let the church do what it wants, despite the zoning. Ken Eftink, the city's development services director, tells me the whole point of zoning a community, is "to have a planned and orderly use of the land." With each question on special-use permits, city officials must decide "if the use is compatible and allowed in the zoning ordinance," Eftink said. If it is compatible, it would mean no special-use permit would be required. If it is not a compatible use, the city has the right to decide what makes the most sense for the larger community -- which could include a decision ranging from giving a special-use permit with specific conditions to barring the activity or use altogether. This, again, is where attending city meetings is valuable -- these decisions which affect you so directly never make it to a ballot. But, during a public hearing, which is required, you get to voice an opinion. Every special-use permit request is reviewed by the planning and zoning board; each one gets a public hearing. If a request is rejected by the board, it is referred to city council's next meeting. At that point, the land owner can ask for the council to hold a public hearing. A special-use permit requires approval by city council. Two public hearings are held, at the first reading and at the councils second and third readings of an ordinace approving a special-use permit. Another part of the city's purpose in having planning and zoning, in addition to orderly land use, is that it sets expectations. A pamphlet from the National Trust puts it this way: "A local comprehensive land-use plan is a road map for a community's future growth, development and, ideally, its preservation. The plan explains the community's overall policies and sets forth a positive vision for how the community should grow. It explains where new homes, businesses, roads, and other community elements should go -- and equally important -- not go." What makes the city council's decision Monday particularly challenging is that the firm representing Angel Food Ministries has now offered to represent Christ Church of the Heartland if the city doesn't agree to let the food sale continue. (Details about that in another blog -- I'm hoping to scan some documents so you can read for yourself.) Let's talk about the food for a minute. What exactly does a buyer get for $25? This month's menu lists its $25 menu as four pounds of chicken leg quarters; four 8-ounce hamburger patties; a frozen turkey dinner; a 1-pound chicken breast; a pound each of sausage, corn dogs, ground turkey pinto beans, rice, vegetables; a frozen Stroganoff dinner; two pounds of french fries; a box of blueberry muffin mix; a dessert; and two pounds of onions. For an additional $18, customers can add four pounds of steak or five ConAgra-brand Golden Cuisine meals. While the program is referred to as "grocery relief," anyone can buy as many boxes filled with these groceries as they like. The program has is open to people of all incomes. (The fact that it is not specifically geared toward the needy is why some people find it difficult to see this program as a charity.) In addition to the above box of food, people can purchase additional food packages, such as 4-pounds of frozen streak (choices include rib-eye, T-bone and Porterhouse) or a five complete frozen meals. Either of those packages cost $18 each. Again, no limit on which kind or how many packages one buys. On the up side, the prices seem kind to the wallet. With wholesale prices -- meaning the more units purchased, the lower the price is -- and no overhead, such as daily costs of a store, freezers, heat, electric lights or employees, the costs are naturally low. Can there be a downside? Well, it depends. While some of the people who made the 900 orders for food through Rev. Strong's church are indeed low-income folks, not all are. In either case, if 900 households stopped shopping at, say Schnuck's or Walmart, and bought the majority of their groceries from Angel Food, what economic impact would that make to the local economy? In a community of more than 35,000 people, perhaps not much. (A question for an economist, yes?) On the other hand, Angel Food Ministries is growing. Missouri alone has more than 350 distribution points. Of the $25 dollars spent of the main box of groceries, $24 is sent to Angel Food Ministries in Georgia. None of the money goes to local paychecks or local taxes. (Given Angel Food Ministries certification by the U.S. Internal Revenue Service as a not-for-profit, no taxes are supposed to be paid on the groceries. The organization is, however, responsible for payroll taxes for its employees at headquarters, and for filing an annual IRS Form 900) I asked Schnucks' manager Dennis Marchi, what he thought of Christ Church of the Heartland's Angel Food Ministries program. "I know some of the parishioners, They've shopped here ... not a lot of them," said Marchi, a grocer for 38 years. Asked about the impact Angel Food Ministries sales could have on his store, he shies away. "I don't even want to go there," he said, adding that there's "no win" in commenting. "I'm leaving it up to city council. We just leave it up to them," he said. Calls placed to WalMart's media relations office, Emmanuel Praise Church, in Monroe, Ga., -- the church that founded Angel Food Ministries in 1994 -- and to Angel Food Ministries headquarters, were not returned. So, that's a little more background on Sunday's story about Christ Church of the Heartland's special-use permit. More later. I look forward to reading your comments and questions and expect civility to prevail. Comments Showing comments in chronological order [Show most recent comments first] |
Hot topics Here's your inoculation against flu hysteria(
Almost -30-
Swine dilemma
Flu, a few words from the CDC {live}
Flu, part 2
|
Peg, your statement, "Of the $25 dollars spent of the main box of groceries, $24 is sent to Angel Food Ministries in Georgia" is not correct. All of the $25 per box is sent to Angel Food Ministries. Then Angel Food Ministries sends each church who placed the orders a donation check. My church participates in the program.
to uscitizen; How much does Angel Food Ministries donate back to your church?
If the city want them to be in a commercial zone then the city should find a building that could be donated to them on that specific day. They shouldn't have to pay to sell these items. You know every time someone in this country tries to do something good for the community someone has to go and screw it up for them. It's all about the money. People these days are just too money hungry.
"Rev. Strong told me he has since had several offers for alternate sites..." If he is really interested in helping people he should accept one of these offers. If he is more interested in making a stink, he should threaten lawsuit. He says, "That's not the issue." He's right, the issue should be helping people, not causing division. It's not right for either side to be stubborn to the point that people are hurt, and that includes the church that has had offers to fix things.
R-1 is R-1! If it illegal to have a distribution service in R-1 so be it. If is not, then issue the "special use permit". Who decided to issue the "special use permit" in the first place? I believe the City leaders should learn the ins-and-outs of R-1 ordinances and teach them to us as well to dispense with all this confusion putting the needy in the middle. That goes for the Church and the City!
Peg McNichol, extremely balanced, well-researched, extensive, and informed reporting. Excellent job!
Several people I know buy this food not for themselves, but to give to friends/family/neighbors whom they know are needy. Bless them for this kindness.
US Citizen --
The story of the 25th dollar:
Though the entire $25 is sent, originally, to Angel Food Ministries' home office, $1 per box of food is returned to the distributing church (in this case, Christ Church of the Heartland).
This is stated quite clearly on the Angel Food Ministries Web site. Also, the Rev. Zack Strong confirmed this fact.
Peg
So if the church sells 900 $25 food boxes that is $900 back to the church. If that is average monthly amount then for the year that is $10,800 all going to the church. That looks like a profit to me.
In addition this looks like more of a power play by the church rather than a mission to help people. My perceived reason the church will not take up the offer to go elsewhere to provide this "service" is that part of the mission is to help grow the congregation. If they take this to an alternate site than it is less synonomous with Christ Church of the Heartland.
This church, I would suggest, should put itself above the fray of the neighbors and branch out to help people. There are many poor people who likely cannot even drive to this church. I say, "Head south Rev. Strong and take your throngs of volunteers to help the many needy people in south Cape."
Mr Bald Guy,
Every month Christ Church uses 2 refrigerated trailers to store cold and frozen food. I am not for sure whether they own or rent these trailers, but they do fuel them. They also provide boxes and sacks to carry the products home, print several hundred menu's for the next month, and provides tables for the other distribution centers to store their food on until they arrive to pick it up.
They also serve as the main distribution hub for churches in Alto Pass, Il, Jackson/Fruitland, Dexter,and others, if a church from "south Cape" would like to become a distribution center all they would have to do is sign up and qualify with the Angel Food program.
I am also curious, do you not think that there are "needy people" in north, east, or west Cape? Is there something special about the poor in the south region of Cape that sets them apart?
Prof Bubba,
The city is begining the legal wranglings, not the church.
I've been reading about all this for awhile and probably shouldn't chime in since I don't live in Cape anymore, but I will anyway. :)
First of all, I went and spent some time a couple of weeks ago watching the "traffic" and listening to the "noise" that this ministry causes. I have a light day at work on Fridays, so I sat there with a book and watched from the far end of the parking lot (much closer than the neighbors that are complaining live). The traffic was non-existent most of the time and even at what would be considered their peak pick-up time, the flow was so smooth it didn't affect the street traffic at all. Noise? No additional noise the entire time I was there, even when there were quite a few cars there for pick-up of food. So if I couldn't hear any noise sitting on their parking lot, how can neighbors hear it a couple of blocks away?
As for moving to another location, there's no need! If the true reason is the noise and traffic, which doesn't appear to be a bona fide reason, that negates the point of moving. Obviously the job is getting done where it's presently located and should stay there.
As for some comments one place or another online along the lines of "the church has enough ministries" and "enough already", in the Bible I read, there are numerous places where Jesus tells his followers to feed his sheep, take care of others, love their neighbor, shine their light, and so on. I can't find one place where He says do only so much. Jesus Himself caused controversy when He ministered to others -- healing the sick & lame on Sunday, etc., and He told His followers that they would be persecuted for obeying Him. He was definitely right!
Try to keep the food limited to those that need it, not to those above the proverty line. If you drive an expensive car, and you order this food package, doesn't it mean you are taking it away from someone who needs it when there is a limited quanity available ?
Augie,
Above or below the poverty line, I have yet to meet a person that doesn't need food!
About 2/3s the way down the article is this sentence, "With wholesale prices -- meaning the more units purchased, the lower the price is..." thus the better the selection and quality of the food delivered. The more people who buy, the better deal everyone gets. It's buying in volume on a mass scale. Like buying a soda from the machine for 50 cents or buying a pallet of sodas for $100.
p.s.
This is not a third world or Communist country, there is no limited quantity of food in the USA. If someone orders a box, they get a box.
A quick clarification on John's comment about the wholesale prices:
"...the more units purchased, the lower the price" does not automatically translate into "bettre the selection and quality of food..."
Angel Food Ministries orders a set menu every month -- which is posted on the Web site -- so people can see what groceries are being ordered. Each month's menu is the same for everyone.
Peg
Sorry, you are not accurate on your statement, "Though the entire $25 is sent, originally, to Angel Food Ministries' home office, $1 per box of food is returned to the distributing church (in this case, Christ Church of the Heartland)." The distributing church does not get the $1 a box. The indvidual churches who placed the orders get the $1 a box. Therefore, in a month of 900 orders $900 is divided between 5 or 6 churches. Please ask these questions to the churches involved before reporting the facts.
John's comment about Angel Food Ministries purchasing large quantities at a lower cost is exactly right. Contact the Angel Food Ministries office and learn how they are able to operate this food program at such a low cost to the individual. They buy the food in bulk at discounted prices and receive Federal Grants to help.
I remember a few years back when the Sylvan Lane residents adamantly opposed the housing development located across the street from Blanchard school. They lost that battle, and they'll lose this one too. In the end, I think the "Sylvanites" will only succeed in helping the Angel Food ministry become stronger than it was before all this controversy started. Good luck Christ Church!
According to the USDA a "retail" operation can accept foodstamps if they are properly registered. The only exceptions for the retail business can be some food pantries, and the like that produce a cooked meal, for consumption there or for takeout. By the way the cost per box is handled (an supposedly all of it is sent to Angel Food Ministries)with a dollar returned to the church.... it looks like to me that this is an operation of Angel Food Ministries, and not Christ Church. Christ Church is only a distribution center (as the angel food ministries implies). A retail operation does not have to be profitable, as many small and large businesses will tell you. Also even though churches usually have a tax exempt status (if they applied properly), churches can still have taxable income. I believe Christ Church would be considered a religious organization and not a church (according to the IRS). Churches are considered to be a recognized denomination, others are classified as religious organizations. Also, there are many not for profit groups...one which may surprise you is Best Western Hotels. Peg, you mentioned an interesting point when you mentioned the Wal-mart distribution center. I figured they probably purchased the food from the international commercial division of Sam's Club, but i never thought about a wal-mart distribution center. Even though Angel Food Ministries purchases the food, they do it at a very discounted rate. I have worked with Wal-Mart/Sam's international commercial division before on large transactions and I know that they don't miss a trick. By previous expierence I think I know what they are doing. You might ask some of the Wal-Mart food vendors (and other vendors) what happens when Wal-Mart doesn't sell a product.......(Wal-Mart gets a credit for the full retail price (even though they only bought at wholesale...AND they don't return the product, but dispose of it as they (wal-mart) see fit. Now through Angel Food Ministries do we have 350 little wal-mart supplied grocery stores in Missouri? Just a thought.... I would certainly like to be a fly on the wall in Wal-Mart's book keeping department to see how they book these transactions.
Quick notes before tomorrow:
John, thanks for the fine question. I was told Christ Church of the Heartland gets a dollar for every box sold. I will verify whether, indeed, other churches are getting them instead.
As for Walmart -- I called that company as I did Dennis Marchi, to ask about the impact of grocery sales on the commerical (as opposed to non-profit) realm.
I do not know where Angel Food Ministries gets their products, other than there appears to be an ongoing relationship with ConAgra for the prepackaged complete dinners. I also read a memo Angel Food Ministries had to send churches after some pot pies were recalled -- they had been part of that month's selection and were delivered prior to the recall notice.
Okay, night owls, see you on the flip side!