*
The Irony Of It All
Brad Hollerbach

Cairo Can Be Added To Corp Playbook in 2046

Posted Friday, May 6, 2011, at 12:00 AM

Comments

View 16 comments or respond
Community discussion is important, and we encourage you to participate as a reader and commenter. Click here to see our Guidelines. We also encourage registered users to let us know if they see something inappropriate on our site. You can do that by clicking "Report Comment" below.
  • will this levee have to be rebuilt after the flood of 2011 ? if so , who will pay the costs , Missouri or Illinois ?

    -- Posted by Smoke. on Fri, May 6, 2011, at 7:29 AM
  • Smoke, I would imagine the sections of the levee that were detonated, will be rebuilt by the Corp of Engineers who built it in the first place.

    Paying for the replacement will likely be all US taxpayers. While the detonation primarily saved Cairo from being (potentially) flooded, actually getting Illinois to pay for the levee replacement is highly unlikely. Their financial situation is very, very dour.

    Now as far as the cleanup of the 130,000+ acres after the waters finally drain away, that is another question. I can't even imagine how long that will take or how many tens of thousands of gallons of diesel fuel will be needed to power the equipment required for the reconstruction. Will the Corp help? They should in my opinion.

    While I feel sorry for the residents of Cairo, I think from a long term economic impact standpoint, the Corp did not choose wisely.

    Thanks for reading.

    -- Posted by Brad_Hollerbach on Fri, May 6, 2011, at 8:47 AM
  • i'm wondering how the people down river feel about the sudden wave of water headed their way .

    IMO , if the Corps made the decision to level the levee , tax payers should be exempt , the Corps should have to find room in their budget to pay for their decision .

    -- Posted by Smoke. on Fri, May 6, 2011, at 8:54 AM
  • Well, I'm a conservative in Texas, and my Dad's an ultra-liberal in California. Both of us agreed (amazingly) that breaching the levee in Missouri was patently unfair. Why should Cairo be spared, when it was their levee that was too short? And are they going to help all the other towns that are being flooded as we speak (now down in Tennessee and Mississippi)? Give us all a break! When will the decision makers in this country (the ones with the explosives, of course) grow some common sense?

    -- Posted by gingercake on Fri, May 6, 2011, at 9:21 AM
  • Brad: Do you honestly think the only reason the levee was breached was to save Cairo? Far from the truth! It helped several communities upstream and downstream, including Cape Girardeau.

    -- Posted by SEMissouri70 on Fri, May 6, 2011, at 10:02 AM
  • I'm a liberal--about 20 meters to the left of Teddy Kennedy (whose hand I once shook)--and I think the levee breach was one of the dumbest decisions any government official has ever made. I would say it ranks with the decision making ability of the POSTMASTER general rather than an army major general, but that would be an insult to all postmaster generals.

    And, to think the one-time flood easement purchased from some of the residents 90 years ago should be payment enough today, explains why native Americans live in campgrounds while Europeans live free: a few blankets and beads in payment are meant to last eternally!

    Brad, you've succinctly said everything I've been posting to various stories for the past week. Thanks for grouping it all together in one spot!

    -- Posted by Just_Wondering1 on Fri, May 6, 2011, at 10:53 AM
  • Of course not, SEMissouri70, but its proximity to the Birds Point Levee makes it the immediate and primary benefactor.

    Is the area protected by its levees equivalent to the Birds Point - New Madrid Floodway? Certainly not. The City of Cairo is just over 7 square miles (not sure if all of that is protected behind levees) whereas the BP-NM Floodway is 200 square miles. It's a much bigger pressure relief valve for the Corp.

    But there is no doubt that the economic impact of this decision is going to be long lasting on the poorest corner of Missouri, affecting not just the people who farm this land as well as farm supply businesses, agriculture processors and every retailer throughout the region.

    Yes, Nil, I did bother to look at data sets for both Cairo and Mississippi County as well as Alexander County, Illinois. They are all impoverished communities. Mississippi County is (now was) statistically better with only 24% living below the poverty line and the bachelor's degree stat is identical. If you earn a college degree, you basically move elsewhere. There's also not a Wal-Mart in Mississippi County.

    But while Cairo is undoubtedly a has-been and never-ever-will-be-anything-else-but-a-has-been, Mississippi County has embraced it's agricultural strengths and made the best of them. I don't consider that a "never was." While agriculture is not a very sexy industry, it keeps the world fed and Mississippi County's 285,000+ acres were well above average in production (In comparison, Alexander County farms about 1/5 that amount of land.).

    Now thanks to the Corps decision they probably lost production on 81% of those acres for this season and more to come.

    TFR

    -- Posted by Brad_Hollerbach on Fri, May 6, 2011, at 11:41 AM
  • Brad: Take a look at the water levels at Paducah. They drastically dropped and the second river crest they were expecting wasn't near as bad as originally forecast due to opening the Floodway. Not to mention, if they did not open the floodway, there is a chance the front line levee might have breeched on its own (not in a controlled way).

    People farming that area knew they were doing well for years. With high reward comes high risk. Farmers always talk about the risk of farming. They all signed on the dotted line below where it stated they were in a national floodway. It is their own fault for farming in an area that could be flooded out whenever needed.

    Maybe the farmers will think twice about farming in that area again.

    -- Posted by SEMissouri70 on Fri, May 6, 2011, at 12:26 PM
  • CAIRO !!! a place of fever, ague, and death. A place without one single quality in earth or air or water to commend it...Charles Dickens.

    Check out James Baughn's blog on this site for the real story about it all. Want to know the future of Cairo? Then go to "Century City" sometime - that's another Illinios town that never was.

    -- Posted by jacksonjazzman on Fri, May 6, 2011, at 12:35 PM
  • One of my favorite "cities" that makes me laugh every time I drive by it is "Future City" right outside of Cairo.

    The future looks pretty bleak, if the name is accurate.

    Oddly enough there exists another equally nondescript Future City in Kentucky just outside of Paducah on Highway 60.

    TFR

    -- Posted by Brad_Hollerbach on Fri, May 6, 2011, at 3:02 PM
  • Brad,

    Cairo is alive & not-well;) This is what happens when reporters & bloggers who don't know their subject are given a sounding board:(

    Please, look at these recent videos of Cairo on youtube. I'm sure depicting Cairo as a drug haven & ghetto sells more papers, but at the expense of the truth.

    http://youtu.be/U_a8RWRCY7A

    http://youtu.be/abxmdTW9Kcw

    -- Posted by cairo58 on Fri, May 6, 2011, at 6:14 PM
  • I do wonder: how many of those Mississippi County acres were cleared of stumps with the $$ the government paid for easements in 1927?

    -- Posted by rain/rain/go/away on Fri, May 6, 2011, at 8:45 PM
  • A few points of clarification, Cairo58:

    (1) This blog appears on a website that is currently free. No one is making any money from this blog and certainly not me.

    (2) I never once mentioned Cairo's crime rate. However, since you bring it up, City-Data.com does rank Cairo highly in several crimes per capita categories including assaults, rapes, robberies and burglaries. The website also says it is #87 of the Top 100 Least Safe Cities in the country.

    (3) As far as I know, nothing in this blog is untruthful. Census data is what it is and most of the information I shared in this blog came from City-Data.com.

    On a personal note, I've been through Cairo several dozen times since the 1980s. While I appreciate the architectural remains of the city from its hey-day, I have observed the city's steady deterioration over the years.

    Frankly, it is very sad. In my opinion, some of the vintage homes in Cairo that sell for $30k could easily bring 20 times that if they were in a larger city. Location, location, location, as the Realtors like to say, and Cairo doesn't have it anymore...

    RRGA, that is a good question. It would be very interesting to know just how much the government paid for easements in Mississippi County in 1927 -- and what those dollars would be today. I will see what I can find.

    TFR

    -- Posted by Brad_Hollerbach on Fri, May 6, 2011, at 11:07 PM
  • >>>This blog appears on a website that is currently free. No one is making any money from this blog and certainly not me.

    The newspaper that you work for is. They sell advertising on this site. Plus, the website is used for advertising for the print edition.

    >>>I never once mentioned Cairo's crime rate.

    No, you didn't, but your bias was clear to see & you confirmed it in your blog replies.

    >>>(3) As far as I know, nothing in this blog is untruthful.

    You omitted much. Cairo has been improving in the six years that I've lived here. We used to be ranked #1 for many of those stats;)

    >>>On a personal note, I've been through Cairo several dozen times since the 1980s. While I appreciate the architectural remains of the city from its hey-day, I have observed the city's steady deterioration over the years.

    It's no longer a "steady deterioration." That already occured. The downtown was crumbling rapidly 6-10 years ago, yet the press keeps showing images of it in reports about Cairo. The neighborhoods are improving.

    You merely repeated what other reporters have been saying about Cairo for the past 10 years. You have to live & work here to see the changes. People from out of town who come here to work (repairmen, deliverymen, etc.) can see the improvements.

    I can see the changes. Admittedly, she's improving at an extremely slow rate.

    -- Posted by cairo58 on Sat, May 7, 2011, at 1:28 PM
  • Brad, you hit the nail on the head. Cairo is a sad little dangerous place. I really wish it was not so but facts are facts.

    -- Posted by jcwill on Sat, May 7, 2011, at 4:23 PM
  • Thanks Brad - my memory lapses, the town is Future City. Illinios is such an interesting state, from our viewpoint on this side of the river..They're sorta like the "Detriot" of the 50 States.

    -- Posted by jacksonjazzman on Sun, May 8, 2011, at 10:43 AM